Sadie enjoys her freedom and her mission trips to Peru, but after four years her Old Order Amish family insists it's time to come home to Apple Ridge, Pennsylvania, and settle down. Levi, a bachelor who distrusts women after a family heartbreak, also has no desire for romance. To keep their families from meddling in their lives, Sadie and Levi devise a plan but soon discover that the walls around their hearts are breaking down. Can they let go of their prejudices, learn to trust each other, and embrace a future together?